The Sealed Letter by Emma Donoghue

I loved the controversial Room, which is why I picked up The Sealed Letter to read – again it’s a story inspired by real-life events, but totally different in style. It’s the tale of a Victorian divorce, replete with scandal, duplicity and betrayal. Fido Faithfull is a successful independent businesswoman in a man’s world; Helen Codrington, her best friend, is by contrast a pampered “man’s woman” always on the lookout for her main chance. When Helen’s affair with an army officer is revealed to her husband, Vice-Admiral Henry Codrington applies for a divorce – a very shocking action in Victorian Britain, where they were fewer than two divorces a year – and the intimate details of their marriage are made public in the papers, to the titillation of society. Helen implores Fido to help her restore her reputation, but to do so Fido must lie in court – will she place her best friend above her principles?

It’s always bizarre to read how strictly controlled polite Victorian society was, at the same time a dark underbelly was scratching just underneath; the speech and actions of the characters are in many ways alien to a 21st century reader, but no less compelling for this. The convoluted nature of a marriage in crisis, whilst the details are strange, the emotions and manipulations are very much not. Friendship is revealed to be as much a deception as marriage in this world where propriety is more important than honesty. Women’s place in society is depicted as precarious, and the infighting between the members of the women’s movement to which Fido belongs is frustrating yet so believable. I like the way this novel takes what is essentially a small event – one marriage – and turns it into a microcosm of Victorian society as a whole. Rating: ***

Picador, 2011, ISBN 9781447205982

The Betrayal of Trust by Susan Hill

Reproduced with kind permission of Vintage
Reproduced with kind permission of Vintage

I seem to be forever recommending Susan Hill to people, either for her wonderful ghost stories or her unusual crime novels. Posters advertising this book are currently plastered all over my local railway station so I hope the commuter population takes note!

I always look forward to the next Simon Serrailler mystery, as much to follow the fortunes of the Serrailler family as to become immersed in the intricate crime story. This latest in the series follows various betrayals of trust at different levels, and Hill invests the domestic plotlines with as much gravitas, care and attention as the murder at the novel’s core.

Serrailler’s life is increasingly complicated and we start to see just how his self-absorption affects those who love him and depend upon him; he is no stereotypical flawed maverick detective, he is simply a flawed human being, and this marks him apart from his peers in the genre. He’s not the easiest protagonist to get to grips with either; he’s elusive and this provokes different reactions in readers who seem to either be intrigued by, or frustrated by, his emotional sleights of hand. Personally I like the ambiguity of his character and the way Hill allows other characters to hold the centre-stage, building Serrailler in a slow but sure reveal.

The theme of this novel is terminal illness, and how different people respond to this emotional trauma; it is genuinely moving and thought-provoking, and builds upon events in previous novels to create a very satisfying episode in the Serrailler saga. Susan Hill’s crime stories stand out for their multi-faceted nature and if you do not normally read this genre, you will be pleasantly surprised by her unique perspective. Hers are stories to take your time with, and savour. Rating: ***

Vintage Books, 2012, ISBN 9780099499343